Post-Publication Discussion Policy

BISMA: Jurnal Bisnis dan Manajemen supports constructive academic discussion following publication. Post-publication discussion provides an opportunity for readers and researchers to clarify findings, raise methodological concerns, identify possible errors, and contribute to the development of knowledge in business and management.

Submission of Comments and Concerns

Readers and researchers who wish to comment on a published article may contact the editorial office by email. Submissions should clearly identify the article concerned and provide a reasoned explanation supported by relevant evidence or references, where applicable.

Email: jurnalbisma@unej.ac.id

Editorial Assessment

The editorial team will assess submitted comments for relevance, academic merit, accuracy, and compliance with ethical standards. Comments must be respectful, evidence-based, and free from personal attacks or defamatory statements.

Where appropriate, the journal may invite the original author(s) to respond to substantive comments. The editorial team will determine whether a comment and response should be published, subject to editorial review and available publication arrangements.

Corrections and Ethical Concerns

If a post-publication comment identifies a potentially significant error, research integrity concern, or ethical issue, the journal may initiate a further assessment under its applicable editorial policies, including its correction and retraction procedures.

Editorial Independence

The journal reserves the right to decline comments that are outside its academic scope, insufficiently substantiated, or inconsistent with its publication ethics standards. All decisions will be made with the aim of supporting scholarly communication and maintaining the integrity of the published record.